Sorrel Design

Evals · Updated 2026-11-18

Grading scorecard

Every study is scored on the same seven axes. The quality gate is 8.0. v1 is the honest baseline. v2 is the first version to pass. v2.1 is the Sorrel Design rebrand with verified Save vs. Splurge picks. Traffic fields stay empty until a scheduled pull fills them — we do not invent saves or views.

AxisWeightv1v2v2.1
Scroll-stop hook0.204.88.88.9
Niche personality & authenticity0.204.28.68.7
Lighting depth & mood0.156.29.19.1
Cross-scene geometry lock0.1598.98.9
Vertical framing readiness0.1068.79.1
Shoppable product desire & fidelity0.155.28.49.2
WebView speed & UX0.059.299
Weighted overall1.005.92Baseline8.76Pass8.96Pass

Below the 8.0 gate

v1 — Compact 48-Inch Desk

Overall 5.92 · graded 2026-11-18

Open the study

Strengths

  • Geometry is tightly locked across the three desk scenes — the original technical win.
  • The study page is extremely fast: static HTML/CSS, one small inline script, lean WebP frames.
  • Night-mode 2700K lighting is a clear step up from the daylight frame.

Flaws & v3 notes

  • The room reads as a sterile office catalog: turned-off black monitor, plain beige wall, empty atmosphere.
  • Scroll-stop hook is weak. Nobody is stopping a TikTok or Reels thumb for a corporate desk.
  • Product links are placeholders on example.com, so desire cannot convert.
  • No 9:16 vertical exports — only 2:3 Pinterest pins.

Honest baseline, not a failure of engineering. v1 proved the scrollytelling chassis, the reference-lock method, and the WebView budget. It did not prove a niche people will save.

Passed the 8.0 gate

v2 — Warm Mid-Century Living Room

Overall 8.76 · graded 2026-11-18

Open the study

Strengths

  • The golden-hour frame has the terracotta plaster, sunbeam, rust sofa, and paper lantern combination the reference board was asking for.
  • The evening lighting transition is the strongest part of v2: official-style Akari glow, amber mushroom lamp pool, dusk window, one candle — same furniture, new mood.
  • Weekend-layer additions (olive Fitz chair, color-block canvas, throw) land without breaking the lock.
  • All six products are real, currently listed, and visually recognizable in the staged room, with verified retailer URLs.
  • 2:3 and 9:16 typography is programmatic, legible, and on-voice.

Flaws & v3 notes

  • These are still AI-staged editorial images, not photographs of the physical products in a real apartment. Close product likeness is not the same as a photo of the exact item on a real floor.
  • A few book spines in the credenza styling have faintly illegible type — a typical generative artifact, small but real.
  • Pin 3 still has a slight overlap between the 'Color Theory' line and the coffee-table candle.
  • Reel 1 crops a sliver off the right edge of the lantern.
  • Affiliate tags are ready but not yet attached, and there is no live traffic in the telemetry block.

Passes the 8.0 gate on visual inspection. v3 should tighten product likeness against the source photos, remove residual text artifacts, and start filling telemetry from real Pinterest and TikTok tests rather than grading on stills alone.

Passed the 8.0 gate

v2.1 — Sorrel Design · Warm Mid-Century Living Room

Overall 8.96 · graded 2026-11-18

Open the study

Strengths

  • Rebranded to Sorrel Design with a broad interiors / offices / lighting / objects voice, and a canonical base ready for sorreldesign.com.
  • Five of six hotspots now carry a verified, in-stock Save or impulse pick ($9.99–$129) beside the Splurge item, including rice-paper lantern, amber mushroom lamp, oval coffee table, and rust and hunter-green pillow covers.
  • Pin 3 typography is lowered so '1930s Japanese Color Theory' clears the candle flame, and Reel 1's crop is shifted so the Akari lantern is no longer clipped on the right edge.
  • The golden-hour-to-amber-evening lighting transition and product-first staging from v2 are unchanged and still the visual core.

Flaws & v3 notes

  • These are still AI-staged editorial images, not photographs of the physical products in a real apartment.
  • A few book spines in the credenza styling still show faintly illegible type.
  • The fluted walnut credenza does not yet have a verified budget Save — Walmart and Home Depot pages could not be confirmed live this turn, and in-stock fluted consoles we could open were over $200.
  • Affiliate tags are ready but not yet attached, the custom domain is not wired, and telemetry is still empty.

v2.1 is a conversion and brand pass on top of the v2 study that already cleared the 8.0 gate. It does not regenerate the room scenes. Next: attach affiliate tags, wire sorreldesign.com, and start filling telemetry from real Pinterest tests.

Telemetry (pre-launch)

Every version carries the same empty telemetry block so a later scheduled job can write into it without changing the schema. Until then, every field is null.